Text Size

SCLogin

Frontpage Slideshow | Copyright © 2006-2014 JoomlaWorks Ltd.

Matilda's On Park

matilda roo

Well, this isn’t going to do anything to allay talk of a curse.

Matilda’s on Park is the latest to occupy the corner of Park and Canton Avenues, the restaurant space that has had a revolving door of occupants for the last decade or so. I listed as many as I could remember when I reviewed the previous tenant, Galopin, in November.

Technically, Galopin didn’t really leave, or at least not the owners. Rather, a partnership was entered into with Ryan Smith, owner of Delaware’s Matilda’s Pub and Mad-Macs, that allowed the rebranding -- and reopening -- to be faster than if a whole new ownership came in. (Indeed, my credit card receipt still had Galopin on it.)

This is the paragraph where I would usually tell you a little about the restaurant: the theme, the cuisine, the atmosphere. But I honestly have no clue.

Matilda’s logo features a kangaroo, so we’re probably looking at the Waltzing type of Matilda. And, in fact, there is a “Roo Burger” on the menu that is made with kanga meat, which, if mine is any indication, is rather dry. It was a beautiful burger, and I liked the coated fries that came with it very much, but the patty itself not so much.

Matilda balls

So then, we’re looking at an Australian themed restaurant, yes? That really wouldn’t explain the tacos or the chicken wings or even the Reuben sandwich. And I admit I’m not up on all the Aussie lingo, but I don’t know what to make of the section of the menu labeled “Balls and Bites,” and I’ll just pause here for a moment while you make your own comment. Oh wait...you may also want to know that the only item of the former is something called Bleu Balls. OK, go ahead. And while you’re doing that, I’ll tell you that the bleu balls are fritters made with ham and chicken. You’re probably also thinking blue (or bleu) cheese is involved, but no, swiss cheese is included. 

Matilda mac

Although I was told that Matilda’s on Park was not meant to be a copy of either of the owner’s restaurants in Delaware, macaroni and cheese dishes are featured prominently, just as they are at Mad-Macs. I ordered the lobster mac, which featured an ultra creamy sauce of cream cheese and mascarpone, tinged with a bit of sherry. What few niblets of meat that were in the dish were small and chewy.

The restaurant space continues to have its dual personality -- triple, if you count the lounge upstairs -- with a casual and contemporary space up front and a more formal (and decidedly impersonal) dining area in the back. The evening I dined, the sets of doors in the front were open wide, even though it was one of our cooler nights. When I mentioned that it cold (and I was sitting as far away as possible) I was told that they had to remain open so the servers could get to a table with guests outside. So for the convenience of the servers, the guests inside must be uncomfortable. I think I get it.

Prices, for the most part, are not unreasonable, though $12 for the mini portion of the lobster mac and $8 for fritters, bleu or otherwise, is a bit much. My roo burger was $13.

My guess is that Matilda’s on Park is trying to be too many things and winds up being nothing. I left fairly confused, and instead of whistling “Waltzing Matilda” I was recalling the lyrics to “Tie Me Kangaroo Down, Sport.”

Play your didgeridoo, Blue. Or Bleu, if you must.

Matilda’s on Park is at 358 Park Ave. N., Winter Park. It’s open for lunch and dinner daily. Here is a link to its Facebook page (a website is not yet up). The phone number is 407-951-5790.

Related Articles/Posts
Raga Now Closed; Transformation to American Gymkhana Underway, Created by Scott JosephRaga Now Closed; Transformation to American Gymkhana Underway...
As of today, Raga, the Indian restaurant on Sand Lake Road, is closed. As I told you in this article, the owners are bringing in New York restaurateur Rajesh Bh...
Vogelbacher Named Executive Chef at Maxine's on Shine, Created by Scott JosephVogelbacher Named Executive Chef at Maxine's on Shine...
George Vogelbacher, right, with Kirt and Maxine Earhart, owners of Maxine's on Shine. George Vogelbacher, longtime area chef with a varied career, has been nam...
Green Day Cafe Moving into Virgin Territory, Created by Scott JosephGreen Day Cafe Moving into Virgin Territory...
Green Day Cafe will take over the space in downtown Orlando's North Quarter District that was vacated recently by Virgin Olive Market at 807 N. Orange Ave. This...
Blackfin Adds Lunch Hours, Created by Scott JosephBlackfin Adds Lunch Hours...
I told you about the return of Blackfin recently. (Here's a link to the review if you missed it.) This week the Maitland restaurant added lunch hours to its sch...
Blackfin, Created by Scott JosephBlackfin...
Blackfin is back. For those of you who have moved here since 2005, Blackfin was a popular restaurant in Winter Park Village that occupied the space currently...

Comments   

 
0 #2 Local Yokel 2013-04-17 14:40
A menu with "bleu balls" on it? Can't quite imagine taking either my mother (she might not pick up on it, though)or my grandkids (but they certainly would) to a restaurant with such a silly, embarrassing named item on the menu. From Scott's review and the first comment from a reader, sounds like this place will be something else soon.
Quote
 
 
0 #1 Jack Miles 2013-04-17 12:44
We were there shortly after they opened; frankly I had high expectations for a pub type atmosphere; something I think would do well on Park Avenue. The reality was my expectations were much greater than the experience. Food took forever and was not worth the wait; staff was nice but rather clueless and management present but not engaged. Food (Burgers) was a long time in arriving and frankly not worth the wait. A good burger is not that hard to serve up. What was most disappointing was the layout, seating and bar. Not sure what folk were thinking but hard to see how you can fit more than 6 stools at the bar and the raised seating, and island seating area is strange at best. May give it another try but it is more my belief that a good, casual, pub/bar on Park Avenue could be a success.
Quote
 
Thursday, 24th July 2014

What is a Flog?

A flog is a food blog with news and reviews of restaurants. Here you'll find all things edible, lots of things to drink, including expert wine advice, and lots of other stuff.


Follow Scott ...

Scott's Newsletter

Please register to the site before you can sign for a list.
No account yet? Register

Flog Advertisement

Featured Links:
Shargaa illustrations
The Best Graphic Design Firm in the Business! (And designer of the Scott Joseph's Orlando Restaurant Guide logo.)
Cucciaioni Photography
Cucciaioni Photography by Eric Cucciaioni, Official Photographer of Scott Joseph's Orlando Restaurant Guide.